Pitfalls of Questions That Make Shia People Silence
Pitfalls of Questions That Make Shia People Silence
To see how weak the Shiite argument is, you only need to ask one key question that makes them silent and can't open their mouths to answer it.
Do not offer them the hadiths about the virtues of the Companions in Saheeh Bukhari and Saheeh Muslim, or in the poles of Sittah. Because indeed they will never believe in authentic hadiths. Instead they will say to you, "That is a false hadith." In fact, it is they who are full of falsehood.
Next I include an example of my chat with a Shiite. Some of the chat I adjust to follow the flow of the theme so it runs.
Me:
"You say that the Messenger of Allah in your hadith has stated about the Companions against Ali. While I know Ali never blasphemed the three caliphs before. Ali never fought them. Ali never asked his followers to hate them. While during the reign of the three caliphs, Ali supported their leadership. So did Ali hide the truth and not reveal it? Does Ali let the Islamic ummah go astray, if you think the Shi'a path is the true Islam?
Shia:
"Ali did not speak because Ali was threatened, even Ali was threatened with death.
Me:
Well, then, why did Ali remain silent when he became caliph? Why did Husein keep quiet when he became a caliph? Is not when they are in power they have power and influence?
Shia:
Shut up
Me:
Mention to me where Ali once asked you to blaspheme friends. Instead you are not following what Ali did. You are not following Ali's path. Ali does not reproach, you reproach. Ali never expresses hatred, you express hatred. Then who are you following?
Shia:
It was not Ali who asked us to do it. But Allah tells us in the Koran. (On another occasion I will reveal verses of the Koran that praise the Companions)
Me:
So, Ali did not follow what Allah ordered? Ali does not follow the Koran? Are you insulting Ali? Ali is not as bad as you think.
Shia:
I will tell you one simple thing. We follow Allah, Rasul and Ali and the Imams. So, if one of them says something, then we follow it.
Me:
Wow, Allah, Rasulullah, and Ali should have said the same thing. Why did Allah and the Apostle say this, but Ali did not say it. Ali should have followed what Allah and the Apostle said.
Shia:
Didn't you read the hadith "Whoever is against Ali, surely they are my enemies."
Me:
Okay, let's say I believe. But unfortunately Ali never told you that ashes and Umar were his enemies. Give me proof.
Shia:
Shut up
Me:
How could Ali let the people go astray to become Sunni, if indeed the Shia was true.
Shia:
I will come back later. (and he never returned)
To see how weak the Shiite argument is, you only need to ask one key question that makes them silent and can't open their mouths to answer it.
Do not offer them the hadiths about the virtues of the Companions in Saheeh Bukhari and Saheeh Muslim, or in the poles of Sittah. Because indeed they will never believe in authentic hadiths. Instead they will say to you, "That is a false hadith." In fact, it is they who are full of falsehood.
Next I include an example of my chat with a Shiite. Some of the chat I adjust to follow the flow of the theme so it runs.
Me:
"You say that the Messenger of Allah in your hadith has stated about the Companions against Ali. While I know Ali never blasphemed the three caliphs before. Ali never fought them. Ali never asked his followers to hate them. While during the reign of the three caliphs, Ali supported their leadership. So did Ali hide the truth and not reveal it? Does Ali let the Islamic ummah go astray, if you think the Shi'a path is the true Islam?
Shia:
"Ali did not speak because Ali was threatened, even Ali was threatened with death.
Me:
Well, then, why did Ali remain silent when he became caliph? Why did Husein keep quiet when he became a caliph? Is not when they are in power they have power and influence?
Shia:
Shut up
Me:
Mention to me where Ali once asked you to blaspheme friends. Instead you are not following what Ali did. You are not following Ali's path. Ali does not reproach, you reproach. Ali never expresses hatred, you express hatred. Then who are you following?
Shia:
It was not Ali who asked us to do it. But Allah tells us in the Koran. (On another occasion I will reveal verses of the Koran that praise the Companions)
Me:
So, Ali did not follow what Allah ordered? Ali does not follow the Koran? Are you insulting Ali? Ali is not as bad as you think.
Shia:
I will tell you one simple thing. We follow Allah, Rasul and Ali and the Imams. So, if one of them says something, then we follow it.
Me:
Wow, Allah, Rasulullah, and Ali should have said the same thing. Why did Allah and the Apostle say this, but Ali did not say it. Ali should have followed what Allah and the Apostle said.
Shia:
Didn't you read the hadith "Whoever is against Ali, surely they are my enemies."
Me:
Okay, let's say I believe. But unfortunately Ali never told you that ashes and Umar were his enemies. Give me proof.
Shia:
Shut up
Me:
How could Ali let the people go astray to become Sunni, if indeed the Shia was true.
Shia:
I will come back later. (and he never returned)
No comments: